| |
STE'86
Registered: Jul 2009
Posts: 274 |
Release id #34889 : Karate Kid
I am objecting Strongly to the inclusion of this blatant rip off in this database.
I think u can guess why.
Steve |
|
| |
chatGPZ
Registered: Dec 2001
Posts: 11111 |
i can guess your reason, but it's not a reason to remove it from the database at all. |
| |
SIDWAVE
Account closed
Registered: Apr 2002
Posts: 2238 |
just delete the damn thing, it has no value at all |
| |
chatGPZ
Registered: Dec 2001
Posts: 11111 |
thats true for a whole lot of the stuff uploaded here, still no reason :) |
| |
iAN CooG
Registered: May 2002
Posts: 3132 |
You could have just set graphic credits to STE'86 and leave a comment about it like "this was stolen from by gfx from here: <insert link to original work of yours>. I've set it right now. Simple as that.
CSDb is for documenting C64 scene, INCLUDING ripoffs of any kind, graphics, musics, re-cracks, any other lame actions.
@Jan: Your "it has no value" is just a subjective reaction. Someone could delete you entire "sid history" because for his taste you've produced just garbage since now. It's just an example, I hope you'll understand this, someday. |
| |
A3
Registered: Dec 2005
Posts: 362 |
This site is for preserving history not changing it. Lame move to do what they did sure. Does this mean that it should be removed. Not really. |
| |
JCB
Account closed
Registered: Jun 2002
Posts: 241 |
I'm with Ian, leave it there and it's got comments now explaining it's stolen, add a credit for Ste, link to his original that way people who think it's ok to pretend stuff is their own actually get found out rather than vanishing...
|
| |
fade
Account closed
Registered: Mar 2002
Posts: 290 |
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DvFormOyvBQ |
| |
JCB
Account closed
Registered: Jun 2002
Posts: 241 |
lol posting that stereotype in a thread about stealing peoples stuff, coming from someone who stereotypically comes from a colony of criminals... about right then. |
| |
fade
Account closed
Registered: Mar 2002
Posts: 290 |
tra la la lalalala worrrrrrld cup
P.S. This pic looks like a bukkake good time :D |
| |
STE'86
Registered: Jul 2009
Posts: 274 |
so why exactly is this a "valid" scene release?
if i today took Veto's (for example) latest pic and replaced his name with mine and reuploaded it under my "released by", would that be a "valid" scene relase?
would u lot let that go?
would you fck.
Steve
|
| |
fade
Account closed
Registered: Mar 2002
Posts: 290 |
Yes we would, if it was under the header of 'fake demo' :) |
| |
Sander
Registered: Jan 2002
Posts: 487 |
I understand the feeling - but i have to agree with the argument of documentation.
Some examples: Warlock (a retouched version..) and Lost Soul (utter lameness). There are loads of these.
Adding the right info would solve it imho.
Funny thing nowadays is that some of these gfx get deleted by the 'author' themselves - when other ppl find out. (mostly coming from the same circles nowadays - you know who you are :) |
| |
chatGPZ
Registered: Dec 2001
Posts: 11111 |
Quote:
if i today took Veto's (for example) latest pic and replaced his name with mine and reuploaded it under my "released by", would that be a "valid" scene relase?
would u lot let that go?
would you fck.
yes we would. we would also laugh at you and point fingers at you =)
Quote:Funny thing nowadays is that some of these gfx get deleted by the 'author' themselves - when other ppl find out.
indeed, typically emberassing ripped and/or converted crap :o) it's not only pictures though, also demos and tunes that people try to remove from history. needless to say that we revert such actions. |
| |
Zyron
Registered: Jan 2002
Posts: 2381 |
What about f ex Aphrodite Demo 1? |
| |
TPM
Registered: Jan 2004
Posts: 109 |
Back then it was quite cool if you could rip music and graphics from original games, change it, pack together and show the world how good you are with your Power cartridge. How many times the cars from Test Drive were ripped? Countless! You call it lame.. in the early days it was cool. Live with it, STE... that was part of the demoscene in '85 - 88 and that belongs to this database.
I know your feeling, but judge it with nowadays insights. It's crazy when you recall your 25 years old rights.. stop whining :) true, your rights will formally stay for 50 years, but no one cares and you'll win nothing when this entry will be deleted. |
| |
JCB
Account closed
Registered: Jun 2002
Posts: 241 |
There's still a big difference with ripping and ripping off. We (Ste and myself) used to do demos in the the 80s with graphics from games be they loading screens, ingame graphics, sprites etc as well as using Ste's original graphics but we NEVER took the names off bitmaps and as far as I remember credited every source we used (even one of the Testdrive cars). Ste's stuff has been used in plenty of demos, sometimes altered (his Alien pic for example) but it's nothing but a compliment IF people give credit where it's due.
|
| |
chatGPZ
Registered: Dec 2001
Posts: 11111 |
somehow the hillarious kimmel vs hubbard thing comes to mind :o) |
| |
Marauder/GSS
Account closed
Registered: Jul 2006
Posts: 224 |
Quote: There's still a big difference with ripping and ripping off. We (Ste and myself) used to do demos in the the 80s with graphics from games be they loading screens, ingame graphics, sprites etc as well as using Ste's original graphics but we NEVER took the names off bitmaps and as far as I remember credited every source we used (even one of the Testdrive cars). Ste's stuff has been used in plenty of demos, sometimes altered (his Alien pic for example) but it's nothing but a compliment IF people give credit where it's due.
Agree, removing/changing signatures is a lame action and sure the most were done by lamers and not the real groups.
Even some of my tools, music-rips or lame crunchers were altered by removing logo or names, so what!?
Anyway I see no reason for deleting the entry. The stuff got spread that way and therefor it's a valid entry here.
Ofcourse, as already said, set the real credits and add some comments or trivia and links to the original picture...
btw, would be nice if you could set/add links in the entry to other entries/productions, some kind of "refers to" or so. Then you could link the fakes together with the original one... not sure the comments stay forever, hehe
just an idea... |
| |
iAN CooG
Registered: May 2002
Posts: 3132 |
Comments can be changed/deleted only by authors of the comment, while credits and all the rest of the infos can be changed by anyone if the entry is not locked. Admins can restore comments even if deleted by the authors, if it's really needed to restore some useful information. So there's no worry about loosing informations even if it's inside comments. |
| |
chatGPZ
Registered: Dec 2001
Posts: 11111 |
"Admins can restore comments even if deleted by the authors"
note "admins". ie, perff. mods even cant see them :) |
| |
JCB
Account closed
Registered: Jun 2002
Posts: 241 |
Quote: somehow the hillarious kimmel vs hubbard thing comes to mind :o)
I had the guy who did the music for our Gallery demo threaten to petrol bomb my house because when he was trying to show his stuff around software houses one of them told him, "not until you stop using Hubbard's code". He presumed I'd been telling everyone... I think most people used Hubbard's routine at one point, especially when the alternatives were Electrosound et al. |
| |
chatGPZ
Registered: Dec 2001
Posts: 11111 |
that said, it would be interesting how many *really* used it :) ian? :) |
| |
iAN CooG
Registered: May 2002
Posts: 3132 |
use sidid =) there's signatures for both
Jeroen_Kimmel
Rob_Hubbard
|
| |
chatGPZ
Registered: Dec 2001
Posts: 11111 |
i dont even have hvsc on my hd, let alone sid related tools =P |
| |
iAN CooG
Registered: May 2002
Posts: 3132 |
For the stats maniacs, this is the complete list of detected players in HVSC#53
Detected players:
128bytes_Tiny 1
256bytes_Tiny 10
20CC 203
8bitDigi/THCM 9
Alexander_Kirsch 3
ALiH 3
A-Man_V1 36
A-Man_V2 20
Adam_Gilmore 46
AMP 200
Andrew_Colin 3
Andrew_Rodger 17
Android 14
Anthony_Crowther 13
Anthony_Lees 8
Anvil 18
Ariston 32
Arne/AFL 48
Arne/SoundMaker_V4 39
Artlace 17
Artline_Design 42
Ash&Dave_Digi 3
Ashley_Hogg 14
Asterion_V1.x 63
Atlantis 26
ATMDS_1.x 5
ATMDS_3.x 11
Audial_Arts 94
Bappalander/Spacelab1 5
Barry_Leitch 25
Basic_program 202
Ben_Daglish 107
Bob_Landwehr 8
Bubble_Bus 3
Bug/NCI 5
Bug/NCI_Digi 14
Burgstaller_B 16
Pretzel/Soundscape 3
Cadaver_Musicdriver_7 2
Cadaver_Musicdriver_10 2
Charles_Callet 2
Chris_Cox 15
Chris_Grigg 7
Chris_Huelsbeck 11
Chris_Walsh 2
ChristopherJam 5
Chubrocker_V3.x 92
Comer_Digi 19
CRD_Tracker 3
CRL/Jay_Derrett 24
Cyberlogic_SoundStudio 93
CyberTracker 103
CyberTracker_exe 85
Cycleburner_Digi 29
Dane 9
Dave_Kelly 6
Dave_Lee 8
Dave_Lowe 12
David_Dunn 36
David_Green 5
David_Thielat/Epyx 6
David_Whittaker 98
Dick_Van_Riemsdijk 64
Digital_Systems 2
Digitalizer_V3.0 83
Digitalizer_V2.x 668
DMC_Vx.x 6942
DMC_V5.x 1997
DMC_V6.x 10
DreamComposer/Tendance 3
DrumEditor 4
Dutch-USA_Team 7
Ed/Wrath 59
Ed/Wrath_Digi 2
Ed_Bogas 7
Electro_Sound 210
Element114Studio_1.0 16
Element114Studio_1.2 6
Element114Studio_2.0 6
EMS_V7.03 129
EMS/Odie 41
Equalizer 37
FAME 40
Flash_Inc_V2.0 4
Flash_Inc_V3.0 10
Flash_Inc_V4.0 27
Frank_Hammer/Sharon 27
Fred_Gray 44
GalBard/ATOO 15
Games_Creator 16
Geir_Tjelta/SIDDuzz'It 620
Gavin_Graham 3
Georg_Brandt 8
Glover 12
Golem 4
GMC/Superiors 378
GMC_v2.0/Superiors 1
GoatTracker_V1.x 1190
GoatTracker_V2.x 889
Goto80/DefMon 6
Graffity/Grabowsky 8
GRG 6
Griff/Chromance 42
Groovy_Bits 60
Guy_Shavitt 77
Hans_Siemons 7
Harald_Rosenfeldt 10
HardTrack_Composer 1115
Heathcliff/DigitalArts 52
Henrik_Jensen 18
Hermit 2
HCL/BoozeDesign 5
Holger_Gehrmann 7
HouseDesign 5
ICC/TheVoice 6
ID_3.x 6
Ivan_Del_Duca 7
Jason_Brooke 17
Jason_Page 8
Jason_Page/Jay 3
JCH_DigiPlayer 3
JCH_NewPlayer 3170
JCH_NewPlayer_V21 145
JCH_Protracker 62
Jeff 165
Jeremy_Hall 3
Jeroen_Kimmel 30
Jeroen_Koops 17
JFK_Digi 4
Jim_Cuomo 4
JITT_1.x 3
John_Halbleib/SSI 4
John_Player 148
Jonathan_Dunn 44
KB/TOM 5
Kosa_Protracker 8
Kris_Hatlelid 5
Kyle_Johnson 3
Lars_Haard 4
LFT 11
Loadstar_SongSmith 15
LordsOfSonics/MS 398
Madhacker_Digi 3
Maduplec 25
Master_Composer 393
Mat/MDA 7
Mat/MDA_digi 9
Microtracker 2
Micropearl/Fitzpatrick 17
MiniMusic/Gentlemen 6
Mixer 7
Mark_Clements 12
Mark_Cooksey 35
Mark_Tait 25
Mark_Wilson 44
Martijn_Schutten 8
Martin_Galway 44
Martin_Walker 16
Matt_Furniss 6
Matt_Gray 34
Megastyle 3
Michael_Delaney 14
Michael_Winterberg 92
Mike/LSD 27
MoN/Bjerregaard 109
MoN/Deenen 106
MoN/FutureComposer 2885
Music_Assembler 5238
Music_Works 2
MusicShop 63
Neil_Baldwin 11
Neil_Brennan 27
Neil_Crossley 6
Network 7
Nick_Jones 3
Nigel_Grieve 7
NinjaTracker_V1.x 15
NinjaTracker_V2.x 7
NordicBeat_Editor 36
OdinTracker 144
Oeyvind_Jergan 8
Olav_Moerkrid 26
OmegaSupreme_digi 9
Oliver_Buettner 2
Oliver_Kirwa 3
Oliver_Klaewer 8
Ozzy_Oldschool 10
Patrick_Payne 7
Paul_Butler 7
Paul_Norman/Cosmi 10
Peter_Liepa 2
Peter_Thierolf 2
Playstar_v2.0 1
PollyTracker 55
Power_Music 32
Prophet64 3
Mssiah 1
Prosonix 52
PVL/Rhythmic_Lunatics 20
Rabbi 13
Rastelin/Bones 3
Reflextracker 130
Reiter_Digi 8
Richard_Joseph 9
RiffQuick 11
Rob_Hubbard 245
Roel_Bosch 18
Roland_Hermans 43
Rolf/Shape 7
RoMuzak_V6.x 448
RoMuzak_V7.x 20
Rule3_Digi_1 6
Rule3_Digi_2 2
Russel_Lieblich 10
Ryo_Kawasaki 25
SadoTracker 20
Samar_Digi 20
Shaun_Southern 5
SidFactory 19
Sidplayer64 16
SidWinder 93
SkylineTech/Badger 22
SkylineTech/Boogaloo 12
Slaygon 20
SoedeSoft 763
Soft_Tune_Composer 1
Song_Writer 7
Sonic_Graffiti 29
Sosperec 79
Soundbooster 33
SoundMonitor 2327
SoundWriter_2.0 8
Sound-Tracker_64 13
Stephan/Bytemare 15
Stephen_Biggs 7
Stephen_Legg 6
Stephen_Ruddy 35
Steve_Barret 25
Steve_Rowlands 11
Steve_Turner 7
Stuart_Taylor 11
SynC 85
System6581 58
TBB/SideB 40
TFMX 20
TFMX/MasterComposer 5
TFMX/TimeComposer 12
TFX 219
Toaster_Digi 11
Tonal_Kaos 7
Toni_Luode 22
Torpex 3
TrackPlayer_V3.0 22
Trident/Active 58
Tiny/Sound_Images 15
Twynn 5
Ubik's_Music 250
Ultimate 5
US_Gold/Novaload 13
Uzzy/Entropy 12
Vanderaart/Radarsoft 10
Vibrants/Laxity 193
Vibrants/JO 107
Wally_Beben/Ariston 38
Walt/Bonzai 92
Wyndex/ISEQ 3
Wyndex/Blahtune 10
Yip_Megasound 61
Zardax/SoundKiller 38
Zardax 54
Zyborg 8
+Digi-Organizer 24
?Unknown_1 3
?Unknown_2 2
?Unknown_3 2
?Unknown_4 2
?Unknown_Kane 2
?Jim_Andron 2
?Summergames/Epyx 2
?Epyx_3 3
?Infogrames 3
?Edge 2
?Howard_Boles 8
?FutureComposer_hack 4
?unknown_digi_1 2
?unknown_digi_2 2
Statistics:
Identified 37253
Unidentified 1461
Total files examined 38714
|
| |
AüMTRöN
Registered: Sep 2003
Posts: 42 |
Where is Mr. Mouse? We *NEED* a graph! |
| |
Oswald
Registered: Apr 2002
Posts: 5017 |
DMC_Vx.x 6942
Music_Assembler 5238
JCH_NewPlayer 3170
MoN/FutureComposer 2885
SoundMonitor 2327
DMC_V5.x 1997
GoatTracker_V1.x 1190
HardTrack_Composer 1115
GoatTracker_V2.x 889
SoedeSoft 763
Digitalizer_V2.x 668
Geir_Tjelta/SIDDuzz'It 620
RoMuzak_V6.x 448
LordsOfSonics/MS 398
Master_Composer 393
GMC/Superiors 378
Ubik's_Music 250
Rob_Hubbard 245
TFX 219
Electro_Sound 210
20CC 203
Basic_program 202
AMP 200
Vibrants/Laxity 193
Jeff 165
John_Player 148
JCH_NewPlayer_V21 145
OdinTracker 144
Reflextracker 130
EMS_V7.03 129
MoN/Bjerregaard 109
Ben_Daglish 107
Vibrants/JO 107
MoN/Deenen 106
CyberTracker 103
David_Whittaker 98
Audial_Arts 94
Cyberlogic_SoundStudio 93
SidWinder 93
Chubrocker_V3.x 92
Michael_Winterberg 92
Walt/Bonzai 92
CyberTracker_exe 85
SynC 85
Digitalizer_V3.0 83
Sosperec 79
Guy_Shavitt 77
Dick_Van_Riemsdijk 64
Asterion_V1.x 63
MusicShop 63
JCH_Protracker 62
Yip_Megasound 61
Groovy_Bits 60
Ed/Wrath 59
System6581 58
Trident/Active 58
PollyTracker 55
Zardax 54
Heathcliff/DigitalArts 52
Prosonix 52
Arne/AFL 48
Adam_Gilmore 46
Fred_Gray 44
Jonathan_Dunn 44
Mark_Wilson 44
Martin_Galway 44
Roland_Hermans 43
Artline_Design 42
Griff/Chromance 42
EMS/Odie 41
FAME 40
TBB/SideB 40
Arne/SoundMaker_V4 39
Wally_Beben/Ariston 38
Zardax/SoundKiller 38
Equalizer 37
A-Man_V1 36
David_Dunn 36
NordicBeat_Editor 36
Mark_Cooksey 35
Stephen_Ruddy 35
Matt_Gray 34
Soundbooster 33
Ariston 32
Power_Music 32
Jeroen_Kimmel 30
Cycleburner_Digi 29
Sonic_Graffiti 29
Flash_Inc_V4.0 27
Frank_Hammer/Sharon 27
Mike/LSD 27
Neil_Brennan 27
Atlantis 26
Olav_Moerkrid 26
Barry_Leitch 25
Maduplec 25
Mark_Tait 25
Ryo_Kawasaki 25
Steve_Barret 25
CRL/Jay_Derrett 24
#NÉV? 24
SkylineTech/Badger 22
Toni_Luode 22
TrackPlayer_V3.0 22
A-Man_V2 20
PVL/Rhythmic_Lunatics 20
RoMuzak_V7.x 20
SadoTracker 20
Samar_Digi 20
Slaygon 20
TFMX 20
Comer_Digi 19
SidFactory 19
Anvil 18
Henrik_Jensen 18
Roel_Bosch 18
Andrew_Rodger 17
Artlace 17
Jason_Brooke 17
Jeroen_Koops 17
Micropearl/Fitzpatrick 17
Burgstaller_B 16
Element114Studio_1.0 16
Games_Creator 16
Martin_Walker 16
Sidplayer64 16
Chris_Cox 15
GalBard/ATOO 15
Loadstar_SongSmith 15
NinjaTracker_V1.x 15
Stephan/Bytemare 15
Tiny/Sound_Images 15
Android 14
Ashley_Hogg 14
Bug/NCI_Digi 14
Michael_Delaney 14
Anthony_Crowther 13
Rabbi 13
Sound-Tracker_64 13
US_Gold/Novaload 13
Dave_Lowe 12
Glover 12
Mark_Clements 12
SkylineTech/Boogaloo 12
TFMX/TimeComposer 12
Uzzy/Entropy 12
ATMDS_3.x 11
Chris_Huelsbeck 11
LFT 11
Neil_Baldwin 11
RiffQuick 11
Steve_Rowlands 11
Stuart_Taylor 11
Toaster_Digi 11
256bytes_Tiny 10
DMC_V6.x 10
Flash_Inc_V3.0 10
Harald_Rosenfeldt 10
Ozzy_Oldschool 10
Paul_Norman/Cosmi 10
Russel_Lieblich 10
Vanderaart/Radarsoft 10
Wyndex/Blahtune 10
8bitDigi/THCM 9
Dane 9
Mat/MDA_digi 9
OmegaSupreme_digi 9
Richard_Joseph 9
?Howard_Boles 8
Anthony_Lees 8
Bob_Landwehr 8
Dave_Lee 8
Georg_Brandt 8
Graffity/Grabowsky 8
Jason_Page 8
Kosa_Protracker 8
Martijn_Schutten 8
Oeyvind_Jergan 8
Oliver_Klaewer 8
Reiter_Digi 8
SoundWriter_2.0 8
Zyborg 8
Chris_Grigg 7
Dutch-USA_Team 7
Ed_Bogas 7
Hans_Siemons 7
Holger_Gehrmann 7
Ivan_Del_Duca 7
Mat/MDA 7
Mixer 7
Network 7
Nigel_Grieve 7
NinjaTracker_V2.x 7
Patrick_Payne 7
Paul_Butler 7
Rolf/Shape 7
Song_Writer 7
Stephen_Biggs 7
Steve_Turner 7
Tonal_Kaos 7
Dave_Kelly 6
David_Thielat/Epyx 6
Element114Studio_1.2 6
Element114Studio_2.0 6
Goto80/DefMon 6
GRG 6
ICC/TheVoice 6
ID_3.x 6
Matt_Furniss 6
MiniMusic/Gentlemen 6
Neil_Crossley 6
Rule3_Digi_1 6
Stephen_Legg 6
ATMDS_1.x 5
Bappalander/Spacelab1 5
Bug/NCI 5
ChristopherJam 5
David_Green 5
HCL/BoozeDesign 5
HouseDesign 5
KB/TOM 5
Kris_Hatlelid 5
Shaun_Southern 5
TFMX/MasterComposer 5
Twynn 5
Ultimate 5
?FutureComposer_hack 4
DrumEditor 4
Flash_Inc_V2.0 4
Golem 4
JFK_Digi 4
Jim_Cuomo 4
John_Halbleib/SSI 4
Lars_Haard 4
?Epyx_3 3
?Infogrames 3
?Unknown_1 3
Alexander_Kirsch 3
ALiH 3
Andrew_Colin 3
Ash&Dave_Digi 3
Bubble_Bus 3
CRD_Tracker 3
DreamComposer/Tendance 3
Gavin_Graham 3
Jason_Page/Jay 3
JCH_DigiPlayer 3
Jeremy_Hall 3
JITT_1.x 3
Kyle_Johnson 3
Madhacker_Digi 3
Megastyle 3
Nick_Jones 3
Oliver_Kirwa 3
Pretzel/Soundscape 3
Prophet64 3
Rastelin/Bones 3
Torpex 3
Wyndex/ISEQ 3
?Edge 2
?Jim_Andron 2
?Summergames/Epyx 2
?Unknown_2 2
?Unknown_3 2
?Unknown_4 2
?unknown_digi_1 2
?unknown_digi_2 2
?Unknown_Kane 2
Cadaver_Musicdriver_10 2
Cadaver_Musicdriver_7 2
Charles_Callet 2
Chris_Walsh 2
Digital_Systems 2
Ed/Wrath_Digi 2
Hermit 2
Microtracker 2
Music_Works 2
Oliver_Buettner 2
Peter_Liepa 2
Peter_Thierolf 2
Rule3_Digi_2 2
128bytes_Tiny 1
GMC_v2.0/Superiors 1
Mssiah 1
Playstar_v2.0 1
Soft_Tune_Composer 1
|
| |
Rough
Account closed
Registered: Feb 2002
Posts: 1829 |
Only 2885 Future Composers? Back when I entered the scene in the late 80s it seemed like billions. |
| |
Frantic
Registered: Mar 2003
Posts: 1627 |
@Rough: I guess it should be kept in mind that some tunes were reused in several different productions. There is probably a billion of releases that use those tunes. ;) |
