| |
Count Zero
Registered: Jan 2003
Posts: 1932 |
Release id #88319 : Robin of the Wood
REQUEST DELETION.
1 Block Basic Loaders represent no release. Original ABC release untouched - no re-crack - double upload - local lamer print line additions to show they owned a c64. What else you need?
l8r
Count Zero/CyberpunX/SCS*TRC |
|
... 34 posts hidden. Click here to view all posts....
|
| |
Jon
Account closed
Registered: Apr 2005
Posts: 247 |
You could have saved yourself all the drama and just deleted it instead of creating this thread.
An aside- Why the sudden interest in what is and isn't worthy of the CSDb?
J |
| |
Count Zero
Registered: Jan 2003
Posts: 1932 |
Actually I wanted to see who is jumping on a bandwaggon to rescue this upload, defend crap in general - it was clear within the second to delete it overall. I somehow lost the bet though - someone is missing on the comment line. :)
To answer your question - which is none of your business to be honest: I am always active on one or the other c64 related project. Sometimes more related to cracks, often less related. It's mainly a matter of time I care to spend on yet another senseless debate with people who apparently define "scene" as include("found 10 minutes between dad and older brother on the c64 and copied this disk!"-schoolyard gangsters).
(Yeye, that 4x4 esi intro ripoff is just the same thing but it definately has its funny parts.)
l8r
Count Zero/CyberpunX/SCS*TRC |
| |
Jon
Account closed
Registered: Apr 2005
Posts: 247 |
That's fine. It certainly is none of my business. But you could have answered politely. Senseless debate indeed.
However, I find it sad that an individual who has added only two items to the entirety of the CSDb has more authority than those of us who have stored these releases for 20+ years on floppy media, transferred the releases over to the PC, read endless stretches of scroll text, and categorised and chronicled them for the Db (which includes adding groups, sceners, the release entry, the D64 image, a screen shot, BBSes, etc etc.
Again, just sayin'.
J |
| |
tnu
Account closed
Registered: Jan 2010
Posts: 42 |
Quote:However, I find it sad that an individual who has added only two items to the entirety of the CSDb has more authority than those of us who have stored these releases for 20+ years on floppy media, transferred the releases over to the PC, read endless stretches of scroll text, and categorised and chronicled them for the Db (which includes adding groups, sceners, the release entry, the D64 image, a screen shot, BBSes, etc etc.
...exactly what i was aiming at earlier....wise words from ninjasbane again.. |
| |
chatGPZ
Registered: Dec 2001
Posts: 11386 |
Quote:However, I find it sad that an individual who has added only two items to the entirety of the CSDb has more authority than those of us who have stored these releases for 20+ years on floppy media, transferred the releases over to the PC, read endless stretches of scroll text, and categorised and chronicled them for the Db (which includes adding groups, sceners, the release entry, the D64 image, a screen shot, BBSes, etc etc.
a) the number of uploads someone did is completely irrelevant when it comes to this kind of discussion (infact, its pretty much irrelevant for pretty much every discussion =P)
b) he doesnt have more authority than anyone else.
c) you have no idea at all what kind of things he has done in the past to support the scene, how much stuff he transfered and uploaded (do i have to mention TDD?) and how much time he spents in various projects just right now. and because of that - read a)
|
| |
Jon
Account closed
Registered: Apr 2005
Posts: 247 |
Groepaz, I never wanted to turn the topic into a discussion about Count Zero. I know that customs and conversational conventions between Europeans and Americans are very, very different. He and I were also a part of a very, very different Commodore 64 scene. The memes and norms of the North American pre-1990 scene is vastly different from the memes and norms of the post-1990 Euro scene. That said, I hold nothing against Count Zero in the least and I recognize his efforts post 1992. I hold nothing but respect for him.
However, I would appreciate a little more arbitration and restraint, especially when an issue like this one arises. I find it a little distasteful for someone to act unilaterally and delete an entry that is not theirs, especially when there is an active discussion about said release.
Having that release on the database harmed no one while its existence was discussed. If the powers that be (or a simple consensus) decided that the release needed to go, I would not have had an issue with it.
J
|
| |
chatGPZ
Registered: Dec 2001
Posts: 11386 |
Quote:The memes and norms of the North American pre-1990 scene is vastly different from the memes and norms of the post-1990 Euro scene.
there was a scene after 1989 ? wow. =P |
| |
tnu
Account closed
Registered: Jan 2010
Posts: 42 |
Quote:a) the number of uploads someone did is completely irrelevant when it comes to this kind of discussion (infact, its pretty much irrelevant for pretty much every discussion =P)
....risking to be mocked and spitted at i say that is a strange view in this issue..this is afterall a database and i see it more important ppl uploading stuff here than posting 4376 times in the forum.....ok...start the flaming now........
Quote:b) he doesnt have more authority than anyone else.
.....that sounds nice but i guess pals from the past have more to say than any newcomer..in general that is.....
Quote:c) you have no idea at all what kind of things he has done in the past to support the scene, how much stuff he transfered and uploaded (do i have to mention TDD?) and how much time he spents in various projects just right now. and because of that - read a)
.....that maybe so...and sure he should be cherished for this...but it is this database we are focusing at....what is uploaded on other sites or databases is not intresting....in this matter may i add..... |
| |
Count Zero
Registered: Jan 2003
Posts: 1932 |
Sigh - "THIS DATABASE" --- which stupid taught you to see databases as garbage dumps?
Any database is only as good as the entries you do. NONE of the MANY uploads I recently checked seems to use the full potential csdb offers for entries. Add scrollers, more than one screenshot, trivia texts, goofs and link up the fuxxored "sentinel docs" and other related things - then we talk again.
There is not even a point in discussing any further with the barriers in your head telling you to protect your uploads instead of improving the record or not saving it in the first place. It's not a race for top uploader here.
There is no excuse for my ONLY two uploads indeed - hm - wait a minute - oh, there is a small one: I am postprecessing ALL uploads here through pokefinder.org.
Not the right place to point out the complete postprocess chain but be assured that some stupid real writer "note to richard" is as useless as an addition as a basic loader for a renamed crack.
l8r
Count Zero/CyberpunX/SCS*TRC
PS: If you want polite talk and smooth explanations - why speak HERE? |
| |
Jon
Account closed
Registered: Apr 2005
Posts: 247 |
Count Zero- Would you prefer that we phone you?
I update and change entries to reflect accuracy all of the time. Just recently I found one of my old phreaking notebooks and I updated many entries from what I found there. I enjoy spending a lazy afternoon reading through old scrolltexts and writing down names, dates and addresses in order to help build a more accurate database. These "Notes to Richard" and Future Writer notes help in that endeavor, despite your insistence that this is "garbage".
This is of no consequence, however. I do so not for kudos or accolades. I simply enjoy revisiting my past and piecing together the missing chunks.
In addition, I didn't ask you to "excuse" you entries. I was simply pointing out that your contributions to the database, if looked at mathematically, may eventually constitute a net loss.
Furthermore, I tire of your anger and hostility as I find it corrosive to rational discourse. Please take a deep breath before you post. I left name calling and rage fifteen years behind me and am happier for it. I encourage you to do the same.
Thanks.
J
PS @ cc85- Groepaz is a very fair mod. Don't get too worked up about this, it'll all be sorted eventually. Just keep doing what you're doing. :)
@ Groepaz- Supposedly there was! It died for me in June of 1989 after five glorious years. :) |
| Previous - 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 - Next |
